Home Reviews Old Forester Rye

Old Forester Rye

February 22, 2019 · By Eric · 8.4 / 10
Rate this bottle ↓
Whiskey Consensus Score
8.4 /10
Very Good
Score Breakdown
Complexity
8
Nose
8.3
Palate
8.6
Finish
8.1
Value
9
Consensus Score
Rated by the WC community
No ratings yet — yours sets the Consensus
Nose
Palate
Finish
Complexity
Value
Add Your Community Score
Nose
Palate
Finish
Complexity
Value
8.4
/ 10
Our Verdict
Very Good

At 100 proof, Old Forester Rye plays beautifully in a cocktail but also stands up boldly on its own. It has a retail price of around $25.

The Good

  • Price
  • Availability
  • Interesting Profile

The Bad

  • Hint of Youth
Old Forester Rye

A little background

After months of looking at an Old Forester Rye label on the TTB website and then reading about the new mash bill (65% Rye, 20% Malted Barley, and 15% Corn) it is finally time to try out the new offering from Brown-Foreman.  It has a retail price of around $25 and comes in at 100⁰.

(Tasted neat from a Glencairn.)

Color in the glass

Light Amber

Nose

Vanilla, wintergreen, spearmint, barley sugar, and sorghum. 

Palate

Starts very sweet with malted barley and vanilla. The rye spice shows up again as fresh wintergreen and spearmint (gum, candy, maybe somewhat like Listerine).

Finish

The “fresh” sensation from the palate continues and eventually fades to brown sugar.

In closing

I was expecting a little more rye spice given the mash bill but was still impressed with its interesting flavors.  Over the last few months I have found that my palate is sensitive to malted barley and it becomes a dominate flavor in any whisk(e)y that contains a decent amount of it in the mash bill, and that is the case here as well.  Those flavors seemed to morph the rye spice into a wintergreen/spearmint gum freshness that I have not experienced with other ryes and that alone makes this a must have in my liquor cabinet.

Old Forester Rye

100 Proof
8.4

Complexity

8.0/10

Nose

8.3/10

Palate

8.6/10

Finish

8.1/10

Value

9.0/10

The Good

  • Price
  • Availability
  • Interesting Profile

The Bad

  • Hint of Youth
Tried this one? Your score shapes the Consensus. Add your score ↓
Old Forester Review Rye Whiskey

Every bottle on Whiskey Consensus is evaluated across five categories on a 1–100 scale. The five scores are averaged to produce a final overall score out of 10.

Nose
Aroma, complexity & first impressions
Palate
Flavor, balance & mouthfeel
Finish
Length, character & quality
Complexity
Depth, layers & evolution in the glass
Value
Quality relative to retail price
Score Rating What It Means
9.5 – 10.0ExceptionalOne for the history books
9.0 – 9.4OutstandingA benchmark expression
8.5 – 8.9GreatSeek this bottle out
8.0 – 8.4Very GoodAbove average in every way
7.5 – 7.9GoodWorth your money
7.0 – 7.4Above AverageA solid everyday pour
6.5 – 6.9AverageUnremarkable but drinkable
6.0 – 6.4Below AverageHard to recommend
5.5 – 5.9Hard PassBetter options at this price
0.0 – 5.4AvoidNot worth your time or money
Eric
About the Author
Eric
Whiskey Reviewer · Whiskey Consensus  · 82 posts

Eric is a whiskey collector and drinker from Huntington WV that enjoys sharing pours with those around him. You can follow along with his whiskey experiences and contact him via Instagram profile @barrelstrength_eric

More by Eric →

Want a recommendation? Ask the Whiskey Genius — our AI trained on every review in the library.

✦ Try the Whiskey Genius

Keep Exploring

Hundreds of expert reviews and counting. Find your next bottle by style, distillery, or score.