Founded February 2017

One Standard.
Every Reviewer.
Every Bottle.

The story behind Whiskey Consensus — and why a consistent methodology is the only thing that makes reviews worth trusting.

Matthew Evans — Founder of Whiskey Consensus

Matthew Evans — Founder

Hi, I'm Matthew Evans

Whiskey Consensus started in February 2017 as an Instagram account — just me, a bottle, and a camera. I was working in digital marketing and technology and wanted a creative outlet that combined my eye for photography with a growing obsession with whiskey. What I didn't expect was for it to become one of the most-followed independent whiskey platforms in the country.

Over the years, a community of contributors has helped build the review library into what it is today — hundreds of bottles across every major whiskey style, each one evaluated using the same five-category scoring system. The methodology has never changed. That consistency is what makes the scores mean something, and what makes every review directly comparable to every other one in the library.

No brand deals influencing scores, no shortcuts, no paid placements — just honest evaluations scored the same way every time. That's what gave Whiskey Consensus the credibility to build an audience of 250,000+ followers, and it's what makes every score on the site worth trusting — each one directly comparable to every other in the library.

Whiskey Consensus has always been more than just reviews. Alongside the scored bottle library, the site publishes recipes, industry news, press releases, and in-depth articles covering everything happening in the whiskey world. If it matters to whiskey enthusiasts, it belongs here.

Outside of whiskey, I'm an ultra distance runner, a car and watch enthusiast, and someone who takes community involvement seriously. The same drive that gets me through a 50-mile race is what keeps this platform running to the standard it was built on.

📍 United States 🏃 Ultra Distance Runner 📸 Bottle Photographer 💻 Digital Marketing & Tech 🤝 Community Volunteer

The People Behind the Pours

Every review on Whiskey Consensus comes from a real person with a real palate — no brand deals, no sponsored scores. Our contributors span a dozen states and a thousand bottles.

Meet the Full Team →
Eric Stumbo Eric Stumbo Sr. Contributor
Landon Shields Landon Shields Contributor
Jake Youst Jake Youst Contributor
Bourbon in Indiana Bourbon in Indiana Contributor
Luther Snow Luther Snow Contributor
Luke Grabowski Luke Grabowski Contributor
Cameron Taylor Cameron Taylor Contributor
Courtney Stiers Courtney Stiers Contributor
Henward Tan Henward Tan Contributor
Sean Duley Sean Duley Contributor
Tiffany McDuffie Tiffany McDuffie Contributor

How Every Bottle Gets Scored

Every review scores five categories independently. No category is weighted — each stands on its own, and the five scores average to a 0–10 overall. This makes every review directly comparable to every other review in the library.

01 Nose Aroma, complexity, and character on the pour
02 Palate Flavor development, texture, and balance
03 Finish Length, warmth, and lingering notes
04 Complexity Layering and evolution in the glass
05 Value Quality honestly weighed against price
Score Rating What It Means
9.5 – 10.0 Exceptional One for the history books. Buy it, cellar it, share it.
9.0 – 9.4 Outstanding Elite whiskey. Worth seeking out at any reasonable price.
8.5 – 8.9 Great A genuinely excellent bottle. Buy with confidence.
8.0 – 8.4 Very Good More good than not. Solid choice for most occasions.
7.0 – 7.9 Good Worth drinking. May not be worth hunting for.
6.0 – 6.9 Average Unoffensive. Better options exist at the price.
5.0 – 5.9 Below Average Hard to recommend. Pour it in a cocktail.
0 – 4.9 Hard Pass Don't bother. Life is too short.

Buying Guides

Ranked best-of lists, head-to-head matchups, and deep-dive batch breakdowns — six guides and counting. Every pick is pulled from the same scored library, so the calls carry the same standard as every review on the site.

Best Of Comparison Deep Dive
Explore Guides →
📖

The Review Library

Bourbon, rye, Scotch, Tennessee, Irish, Japanese, and beyond — every bottle scored the same way by real reviewers with no brand influence. One consistent standard across every style, so every score actually means something. Filter, sort, discover.

Browse All Reviews →

WC Whiskey Club

Free to join. The WC Whiskey Club gives members early access to upcoming releases, first notifications on new barrel picks, and exclusive opportunities to purchase limited-edition selections before they're gone.

  • Early notifications on upcoming releases
  • First access to new WC barrel picks
  • Exclusive limited-edition purchase opportunities
  • Past picks include Jack Daniel's Single Barrel Barrel Proof Rye WC16 and NULU Toasted Maple Bourbon WC7
Join Free →

Work With Me

Whiskey Consensus reaches 250,000+ engaged followers across Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok, plus a growing email list and web audience. I partner selectively with brands on reviews, barrel picks, photography, and promotions — always with full transparency to the audience.

  • Bottle reviews and featured coverage
  • Custom barrel selections and picks
  • Bottle photography and content creation
  • Social media campaigns and promotions
Get in Touch →