Skip to content
Whiskey Consensus Logo
  • About
  • Reviews
  • Articles
    • Press Release
    • Recipes
  • WC Whiskey Club
  • Whiskey 101
  • Connect
  • Toggle website search
Menu Close
  • About
  • Reviews
  • Articles
    • Press Release
    • Recipes
  • WC Whiskey Club
  • Whiskey 101
  • Connect

My Profile

settings
person About
create Posts
comment Comments
[…] Whiskey Consensus notices a banana and nutty nose with subtle hints of oak, vanilla, and fruit. The finish is…
On J.W. Dant Bottled in Bond
I am surprised you were able to do it neat! Had a couple samples of a 143 proof barrel. While…
On Jack Daniel’s Single Barrel 2021 Special Release Coy Hill High Proof
Awesome sauce for the price!
On Old Overholt 114 Proof Special Release Straight Rye Whiskey
Like many Bourbons or Scotches, this needs to breathe a little before you indulge. Be patient with this one. It…
On Blood Oath Pact No. 7
Old Forester makes some very delicious Whiskey! Some reviews I saw had a negative connotation due to preconceived notions based…
On Old Forester Statesman Bourbon
Totally agree with your assessment of this fine bourbon. Going for about $12 in SE Indiana and always available. Always…
On J.T.S. Brown Bottled in Bond
I do not wish to post notes at this moment but rather enjoy the dram (again). However, if I must,…
On Ardbeg Uigeadail
hangover central. This liquid should be labeled as a poison.
On Starlight Distillery Indiana Straight Single Barrel Bourbon
I've had Blue label before; my experience is similar. It's not bad. That said, "not bad" and US$200/750ml bottle do…
On Johnnie Walker Blue Label
I have just tried the Starlight Carl T. Huber's single Barrel Bourbon Whiskey finished in Honey Barrels and I can't…
On Starlight Distillery Indiana Straight Single Barrel Bourbon
See More Comments

Categories

Recent Reviews

  • Bardstown Bourbon Company Cascadia Garryana Oak Barrel Finish
    Bardstown Bourbon Company Cascadia Garryana Oak Barrel Finish
    March 30, 2026/
    0 Comments
  • Barrell Bourbon 12 Year Finished in Toasted American Oak Casks
    Barrell Bourbon 12 Year Finished in Toasted American Oak Casks
    March 29, 2026/
    0 Comments
  • Ampersand Vinea
    Ampersand Vinea
    March 12, 2026/
    0 Comments
  • Ampersand Malus Rye Whiskey
    Ampersand Malus Rye Whiskey
    March 5, 2026/
    0 Comments
  • Still Austin Cask Strength Rye Whiskey
    Still Austin Cask Strength Rye Whiskey
    February 21, 2026/
    0 Comments

New Articles

  • Jack Daniel’s Debuts High Proof, Small Batch Rye from Three Unique Barrelhouse Locations
    Jack Daniel’s Debuts High Proof, Small Batch Rye from Three Unique Barrelhouse Locations
    April 21, 2026/
    0 Comments
  • Barrell Craft Spirits® Introduces its First Cigar Blend Bourbon
    Barrell Craft Spirits® Introduces its First Cigar Blend Bourbon
    March 30, 2026/
    0 Comments
  • Penelope Bourbon evolves its award-winning barrel strength offerings with Barrel Strength 7-Year
    Penelope Bourbon evolves its award-winning barrel strength offerings with Barrel Strength 7-Year
    February 17, 2026/
    0 Comments
  • CHRIS STAPLETON AND BUFFALO TRACE MASTER DISTILLER HARLEN WHEATLEY INTRODUCE TRAVELLER WHISKEY FULL PROOF
    CHRIS STAPLETON AND BUFFALO TRACE MASTER DISTILLER HARLEN WHEATLEY INTRODUCE TRAVELLER WHISKEY FULL PROOF
    February 11, 2026/
    0 Comments
  • Green River Expands Award-Winning Lineup with Launch of Wheated Full Proof Bourbon
    Green River Expands Award-Winning Lineup with Launch of Wheated Full Proof Bourbon
    February 10, 2026/
    0 Comments

Whiskey Consensus Top 10

  • Elijah Craig Barrel Proof Batch B516 Proof 139.4
    9.6
  • Booker’s 30th Anniversary
    9.5
  • Michter’s 20 Year Bourbon (2019 Release)
    9.5
  • William Larue Weller (2020)
    9.4
  • Four Roses Limited Edition Small Batch (2019 Release)
    9.4
  • Jack Daniel’s 14 Year Old Tennessee Whiskey (Batch 1)
    9.4
  • William Larue Weller (2018 Release)
    9.4
  • Mister Sam Tribute Whiskey
    9.4
  • Old Fitzgerald Bottled-In-Bond: 15 Year (Fall 2019)
    9.4
  • Lux Row Distillers 12 Year Double Barrel
    9.3

Whiskey Consensus Rating Scale

Score Explanation
9.5 – 10 Exceptional. One for the history books.
9 – 9.4 An Outstanding Whiskey
8.5 – 8.9 Great
8 – 8.4 Very Good
7.5 – 7.9 Good
7 – 7.4 Above Average
6.5 – 6.9 Average
6 – 6.4 Below Average
5.4 – 5.9 Hard Pass
0 – 5 Avoid
Whiskey Consensus Footer Logo
  • About
  • Reviews
  • Articles
    • Press Release
    • Recipes
  • WC Whiskey Club
  • Whiskey 101
  • Connect
Facebook-f Instagram Twitter Pinterest
Whiskey Consensus Footer Logo
  • About
  • Reviews
  • Articles
    • Press Release
    • Recipes
  • WC Whiskey Club
  • Whiskey 101
  • Connect
Facebook-f Instagram Twitter Pinterest
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
Copyright 2026 - Whiskey Consensus

Stay in the Know!
Be the first to know about new whiskey releases, in-depth reviews, exclusive tastings, and industry insights—delivered straight to your inbox.
👉 Sign up today and never miss a pour.

WC Barrel Club

Join the Whiskey Consensus Barrel Club for first access to upcoming private barrel picks and special releases!