Old Carter Whiskey Co. is the brainchild of Mark and Sherri Carter, the producers of fine Napa Valley wines under the name Carter Cellars. According to Mark and Sherri, “Old Carter Whiskey Co. is focused on creating totally unique, very small-batch, straight rye and bourbon whiskies. “We create our spirits from the heart, each one a single expression of what we love.” From selecting barrels, creating new blends, and handwriting each individual label by hand, the Carters do it all. Since the first releases in 2018, quite a few different batches of Old Carter have been released, ranging from less than 100 bottles per batch to over 2,000. This review is for the 2020 release of Old Carter Rye Batch 6. This batch is a blend of barrels that were hand selected and distilled in Indiana. Batch 6 is a barrel strength 116.3 proof rye with a price tag of around $200.
(Tasted neat from a Glencairn Glass)
Color
Dark Caramel
Nose
Old Carter Rye Batch 6 has a nose that is very floral with a touch of sweetness that shines through as it opens up. Notes of citrus and spice linger in the background.
Palate
The palate carries over the florality that is apparent on the nose but really accentuates the sweetness and spice notes in the form of caramel and red hot candies. A big fresh mint note really pops as well.
Finish
This rye has a very long finish; however, it not overpowering at all. Notes of mint, butterscotch, caramel, and those red hot candies really shine through.
In closing
Old Carter Rye Batch 6 is a very good rye that any whiskey buff would love to have in their collection. The price is pretty steep at $200, but the flavor deliveries with this one if you are a fan of barrel proof ryes.
Small town guy from Indiana that enjoys trying new bourbons and sharing them with his friends and family. For him, bourbon started as a hobby and quickly turned into a way to connect and interact with new people. You can find/contact him on Instagram @bourbon_in_indiana
Leave a Reply
Stay in the Know! Be the first to know about new whiskey releases, in-depth reviews, exclusive tastings, and industry insights—delivered straight to your inbox. 👉 Sign up today and never miss a pour.
WC Barrel Club
Join the Whiskey Consensus Barrel Club for first access to upcoming private barrel picks and special releases!